777 NORTH PROSPECT AVE
North Tier 3 & North Park 3
The Cudahy Building
Milwaukee, WI
Framed by sweeping views of Lake Michigan, the War Memorial, and the Calatrava, this impeccably renovated double residence within The Cudahy – an architecturally significant pre-war landmark – reflects the scale and craftsmanship of one of Milwaukee’s most distinguished addresses. The 3,214-square-foot primary residence features bay windows, refined moldings, custom millwork, multiple fireplaces, and water and skyline vistas throughout. An adjoining 1,248-square-foot guest suite with private entrance offers flexibility for extended family, guests, or discreet live-in support. A rare, turnkey lakefront residence of architectural significance and enduring presence.
Property Features
- 4,461 total square ft
- 2 Units – NP3 & NT3
- 4 Bedrooms | 3.5 Bathrooms
- Year Built: 1907
- Extensive Renovations in 2021
- 2 Garage Parking Spaces
- 1 Leased Parking Space
North Tier 3
- 3 Bedrooms
- 2 Bathrooms
- 3,213 Square Feet
- Views Lake Michigan, Calatrava, War Memorial
North Park 3
- 2 Bedrooms
- 1.5 Bathrooms
- 1,248 Square Feet
- Views Private Greenspace
Building Amenities
- 24/7 On Site Security
- Private Greenspace
- Library
- Dog Friendly
- Fitness Center & Sauna
- Shared Veranda
THE CUDAHY
The Cudahy condominium building, along with the adjacent Cudahy Tower Apartments, was redeveloped by Michael Cudahy after he acquired both properties in the 1980s. The Cudahy was originally constructed in 1907, and the Cudahy Tower Apartments were built in 1927.
Michael Cudahy converted The Cudahy into 44 residential condominium units and one commercial unit, while the northern building remained apartments. Following redevelopment, Michael assumed management of both properties, later transitioning day-to-day management to his daughter, Julie Cudahy.
In 2021, Julie stepped away from managing the condominium building. At that point, the HOA Board hired Founders3 as the professional management firm. Founders3 also manages several prominent downtown Milwaukee buildings, including University Tower and The Kilbourn. This change marked a significant upgrade in financial controls, maintenance oversight, reserve planning, and security operations.
Following Michael Cudahy’s passing in 2022, the Cudahy family sold the apartment building (Cudahy Tower Apartments) to Shoreline Real Estate, a family-owned firm that owns and manages a substantial portion of Milwaukee’s East Side vintage apartment buildings. The condominium building (The Cudahy) and the apartment building are now entirely separate entities, with separate legal documents, finances, reserve studies, repair schedules, management, and security. The only shared elements are a common wall & underground parking.
BUILDING
NORTH TIER UNIT
NORTH PARK UNIT
